At SVAC Hearing, Senator Murray Presses VA, Oracle on Flawed Electronic Health Record Modernization Program

***WATCH: Senator Murray’s full questioning***

Washington, D.C. — Today, at a Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee (SVAC) hearing, U.S. Senator Patty Murray (D-WA)—a former chair and senior member of SVAC—questioned Dr. Neil Evans, Program Executive Director (PED) of VA’s Electronic Health Record Modernization (EHRM) Integration Office, and Mike Sicilia, Co-CEO of Oracle Health, on the serious issues and system defects that remain unaddressed with the EHR program.

Senator Murray has been conducting oversight of the flawed EHR system rollout in Washington state since the Trump administration first negotiated the contract with Cerner (later acquired by Oracle), and at every point in the process since then. Murray has consistently pushed VA on its failed implementation of EHR—conducting oversight, holding the administration accountable, and, in 2022, calling on VA to halt the deployment of EHR in Washington state until it was fixed. In March 2023, Murray introduced comprehensive legislation that would require VA to implement a series of EHR reforms to better serve veterans, medical personnel, and taxpayers. In the Fiscal Year 2024 funding bills that Senator Murray negotiated and passed as then-Chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee, Murray secured key provisions to better hold VA and Cerner accountable for the rollout of the EHR system. In May 2024, she sent a letter urging VA to consider feedback on the system from providers and veterans in Spokane and Walla Walla and reiterating that VA must not move forward on the rollout of EHR until the myriad issues that have plagued the system are fixed.

Last year, Senator Murray grilled Secretary Collins during his confirmation hearing on how he would prioritize fixing the issues with the EHR system before deploying it to more sites, and she has continued to press Secretary Collins to fix unresolved issues with the EHR system. As Vice Chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee, Senator Murray fought to secure provisions in the Senate Military Construction, Veterans Affairs, and Related Agencies (MilCon-VA) appropriations bill for Fiscal Year 2026 that improve oversight and accountability of EHR. The legislation provides $3.4 billion to improve the EHR modernization effort and makes 30 percent of funds contingent upon the VA Secretary providing to Congress detailed information on EHR.

[WA EHR DEPLOYMENTS]

Senator Murray began by asking Dr. Evans if EHR will work with research partners to avoid disruptions to patient care, noting how the previous attempt at implementation at the Mann-Grandstaff VA Medical Center in Spokane, Washington put the lives of veteran patients at risk.

MURRAY: It has been over six years since the VA launched its first EHR deployment at the Mann-Grandstaff VA in my home state of Washington. It was a complete disaster. It literally put veterans’ lives in danger. So, it won’t surprise you to hear that I’m very skeptical about deploying the system to other VAs in my state.

Dr. Evans, Puget Sound is the largest VA in Washington and the specialty care hub for Alaska, Idaho, and Montana. VA is scheduled to roll out EHR there next year. Ahead of this next Washington deployment, have you spoken directly with providers at Mann-Grandstaff about the lessons learned?

EVANS: Yes.

MURRAY: Do you want to tell us what they told you?

EVANS: Sure. First of all, I’ve spoken, I’ve been to Man-Grandstaff several times in person. In fact, when we started, it was frankly in partnership with you and the prior hearing. Which is a hearing when I had been on the job for a month, where you encouraged us to.

MURRAY: I just want to know what they told you.

EVANS: They shared with us some of the challenges, but they also, I will argue, have been incredibly helpful in providing feedback that has led to some of the 13,000 changes that we have made to the system. In part, because we have learned from what they shared. So I would argue that the staff at Mann-Grandstaff and the staff in Walla Walla, and frankly all of our original sites in the Pacific Northwest, are staff that we have a significant debt of gratitude to for their—

MURRAY: I appreciate that, but I think you know there are still concerns, and I’m hoping you’re talking to them before you roll this out.

Let me just say that one of the failures in the past EHR rollouts was that the VA systems couldn’t work with research universities and partners. The Puget Sound VA works with outside partners, including the University of Washington, to [research] groundbreaking new treatments for veterans. Can you assure me today that VA has resolved those issues coordinating with its research partners, so this EHR rollout won’t mean disruptions in clinical research and in patient care?

EVANS: Yes, absolutely. You may recall that one of the reasons why we were on track to go live in Ann Arbor, numerous years ago, and we stopped that go live because of concerns about our ability to adequately support the research mission in Ann Arbor. Ann Arbor has partnerships with the University of Michigan and other.

MURRAY: Have those been resolved?

EVANS: And those have all been resolved. So we’ve gone live in Ann Arbor. We went live with over 100 clinical trials in Ann Arbor and have been very successful at doing so.

MURRAY: So you can assure me today that there won’t be any disruptions when you go live with any of their partners, including, as I said, research and patient care.

EVANS: That’s correct.

MURRAY: There will not be, none. You’re testifying to that today?

EVANS: We work closely with Oracle. We actually send a team, there actually is a dedicated team from Oracle that supports working with our principal investigators to make sure that we are getting the build right for each of the clinical research trials. This has been a proven model over all of the medical centers over this past year where we do support research, and we will of course be doing the same when we go to Seattle.

MURRAY: Well let me just say that after the missteps we have seen, I want to put you on notice today that I am watching like a hawk to make sure quality service and veteran safety are being prioritized every step of the way.  

[COST OF EHRM TRIPLES]

Senator Murray continued by asking Dr. Evans and Mr. Sicilia about miscalculations and incorrect estimates made on EHR records, users, and time frame.

MURRAY: Oracle told my staff that its EHR contract increased a whopping $17 billion because there were changes in the scope of the project. Between 2018 and 2026, the number of veteran records increased from eight million to over 26 million. Apparently, VA got this estimate dead wrong under the first Trump administration. 

Dr. Evans, when did VA realize the project was more than three times larger than originally negotiated?

EVANS: So I’ll first say there, we shared that a year ago, as I’ve mentioned the cost estimate. So we have certainly been aware of what the costs are going to be, in part because of the realization that the estimate, so I’ll just take us back to 2017 and 2018. That estimate of $9.996 billion, that was the original ceiling estimate, was an estimate based on an assumption of what it would take to successfully deploy the federal EHR. We together have learned a lot. We have increased, for example, you heard mentioned of learning labs. We added learning labs. That was not—

MURRAY: Okay. My question was, and I will run out of time here, and I have more questions because the estimate was way off. Oracle also said that, in addition to record increases, there was a 129 percent increase in end users. How do you explain that? I’m really confused about how this number is increasing when the Trump administration is simultaneously putting a hiring freeze on VA clinical staff. These miscalculations are a big red flag to all of us, and we need more information on how VA comes up with these estimates that apparently were really wrong. That’s what I’m very concerned about.

Mr. Sicilia, in July 2022, you told this committee that Oracle would provide VA with an EHR system that exceeds expectations without exceeding the contracted cost. Was that a promise that you kept: yes or no?

SICILIA: I believe that what was contemplated at that time is very different than what’s been delivered today, and I believe that we have delivered on after the reset on the redesigned program.

MURRAY: Well, let me just say that more than tripling the cost of the project kind of feels like a no to me. 

And you’ve also said the number of interfaces Oracle has to build to connect to other systems has also increased by 187 percent since 2018. So let me just ask you, does the new contract account for future work to connect to those other systems?  

SICILIA: The new contract, the contemplated IDIQ, takes into account all of the scope changes that we made. All of the additional interfaces, and they continue to roll out to complete the VAMC rollout. That is all in the new IDIQ. The question is about value versus cost. I want to go back to what I said about a sincere commitment. If Congress believes that the system doesn’t have value, that is something that only Congress and the VA can ultimately decide. We made every effort to deploy this system as efficiently and as cost-effectively as we can. If Congress believes that the cost is simply too high, but the value is still there, I would encourage you to challenge us.

MURRAY: Look, what I’m just saying is, you told this committee that the system would exceed expectations without exceeding the contracted cost. We are here not much later, and it’s done that considerably. So, Mr. Chairman, let me just say I want to make sure that you are not going to walk away after the end of this contract and leave veterans with a system that still doesn’t work. We all know veterans deserve access to the best health care technology, and you are responsible for upholding that promise to them.  

###